ENZB - 1961 - The Richmond-Atkinson Papers Vol I

HISTORY OF THE COLLECTION

History of the Collection

The survival for almost a century of the collection now known as the Richmond-Atkinson Papers was not a mere chance. It was due primarily to the congenital disposition of a family for recording and sporadic impulses towards conservation.

The Richmonds and Atkinsons and their relatives were a unique group of middle-class English men and women. Educated and cultured, many were efficient in the practical crafts of colonisation, and most showed an aptness for public service. Between 1843 and 1856 there was a movement of related groups from the Old World to the Antipodes which somewhat resembled the preparatory hekes of Maori communities from one district or island to another.

In the early days of this dispersal there was a lively interchange of news and impressions between the hemispheres, a simple family traffic. As the leaders of the colonists were drawn into public life their correspondence was broadened accordingly. Letter writing became more general and the instinct for documentation was unconsciously fostered. Thus the written memorials of this first generation embraced not only the rustic interests of bushfarmers but in succession the affairs of the township, the province, and the Colony at large. Before New Zealand was fifty years old these records were nationwide. Little indeed of our early history escaped the lively cognisance of these eager scribes.

The core of the collection may be said to reside in the letters and diaries of the five Richmonds and three Atkinsons and the diaries of Arthur S. Atkinson. There is in addition a mass of letters from political leaders and intellectuals all over New Zealand and abroad.

The Richmonds were superb letter writers: calligraphy and English were alike faultless. Maria Richmond (1791-1872), the matriarch of the emigrants, occasionally kept a journal, but she appears at her best in the letters of a woman of culture and discernment, interested in literature and philosophy and alert to current events. A counsellor of the new generation and a commentator on affairs, she shrewdly judged men and was a tolerant assessor of human motives. Some of her character sketches assist pleasantly to clothe with flesh and blood such historical figures as Alfred Domett and Sir Edward Stafford.

Maria Richmond's eldest son, (Christopher) William Richmond (1821-95), kept a fugitive diary at intervals in a busy life. His reflections and public acts are mainly to be found, however, in the archives of Government, Parliament, and the Supreme Court. Amongst his papers are some of an official character which would normally have come to rest in the National Archives if clerks had been available to relieve him of the double duty of writing the letters and keeping the records. Special value

[Image of page 6]

accordingly attaches to carbon copies of his correspondence in the fifties (vol 41) and a manuscript letter copybook (vol 42) covering spasmodically the periods 1854-59 and 1877. These may prove to contain the sole record of certain exchanges between Richmond as Colonial Secretary and the Governor (Col. T. Gore Browne) in the crisis of the Taranaki war and in the establishment of responsible government. In later life, when he was more congenially employed as a judge, Richmond was often engaged by fellow intellectuals in debating such topics as materialism, Christian socialism, religion, and social reform. Many of his speeches and lectures and addresses to the jury were published in England and in the Colony. His swift clear hand, despite the frequency of legal abbreviations, left nothing obscure in his meaning.

The second son, James Crowe Richmond (1822-98), later recognised as one of New Zealand's most talented artists, is strongly represented also as engineer, journalist, free-thinking philosopher, and administrator. He wrote in a swift copperplate hand. There are some letters too by his wife, Mary Smith (1834-65), whose courtship is commemorated in a striking series. Of their artist daughter, Dorothy K. Richmond, there are some letters.

The youngest of the Richmond sons, Henry R. Richmond (1829-90), had a strong bent for physical science and essayed some forward-looking theories hinting at the atomic age. Shrinking from public life, he corresponded with scientists oversea with a sturdy wistful curiosity.

Running throughout the collection like a continuous thread are the letters and diaries of Jane Maria Richmond (1824-1914), whose marriage to Arthur Atkinson reinforced the union of the families and strengthened their influence on the New Zealand tradition. Her education specialised in literature, music, and art. Warmhearted and outspoken, she was eminently practical and possessed an Amazonian spirit that shirked no dilemma and flinched at no aspect of physical danger. Arthur Atkinson (1833-1902) was several years her junior and the best educated of the Atkinsons. He was devoted to the classics and philology, poetry and the study of nature. Even in the Richmond circle he is distinguished for his patiently polished letters and his excellent journals. A painstaking, methodical recorder, each day for a quarter of a century he noted not only local events - exciting or humdrum as the case might be - but also his own dip into the classics, his observations on birds, the stars and the weather, or some new Maori idiom or legend. In him poesy and scholarship flourished about the hard core of endeavour and duty.

Jane Maria and her husband were passionate champions of the tortured province in which their lot was cast. In its defence they yielded to the hot temper of politics and bitterly attacked the general government, even when William Richmond happened to be a member of it. Inevitably in those days of isolation and remoteness public feeling was at the mercy of rumour and gossip. In common with their friends Mr and Mrs Atkinson occasionally gave currency to the sort of scandal that such primitive circumstances engendered. This is not surprising, for political partisanship was nothing new to men and women who had lived in England in the forties.

[Image of page 7]

Generally speaking, mere gossipy passages have not been considered worthy of reproducing in this publication. If the question is asked: Why give them at all? the answer is that such trivia, committed to writing by men and women of education and social standing, afford evidence of the background or climate in which our grandfathers lived. To ignore them would rob the chronicle of a measure of human warmth that must be helpful in interpreting the times.

Harry A. Atkinson (1831-92) was essentially a man of action. The diary that he kept now and again was only for farm purposes. His writing, though quite without style, is never obscure. The. intimate correspondence of the two Atkinson brothers during the later decades of Sir Harry's life documents with peculiar authority the political background of the period and stands high as source material.

The letters of these half dozen or so members of the two families maintain a substantial thread of history through the collection. There are, in addition, many hundreds of letters from thinkers and men of action in the Colony and beyond.

Arthur Ponsonby, surveying the material at hand for the life of his father, reflected on the family habits of keeping or destroying letters:

There may be no particular intention or merit in either practice but posterity is grateful to those who do not destroy their papers, because ... a number of letters describing the day's doings, referring to unknown people or recording trivial events have the cumulative effect of giving the atmosphere, domestic or professional, and revealing the character, the disposition, and even the passing moods of the writer. 1

Amongst the Richmond-Atkinson group were many correspondents who are easily recognisable as "keepers and not destroyers". The keeping impulse was awakened early amongst the colonists by the controversy over the Taranaki war. In 1860 - for the first time in history, we are told - British volunteers were in action in a military campaign. The Taranaki volunteers at Waireka were not adequately supported by the British military commanders and unhappy recrimination ensued between settlers and soldiers. To satisfy the curiosity of William Richmond (who was in Auckland) and to ensure that the conduct of the volunteers would be rightly appraised, the two Atkinsons and the Ronalds brothers wrote separate narratives of their experiences in the engagement.

A year or two later the Atkinsons were urged by James Edward FitzGerald to write a history of the war. Another crisis pushed the project aside but the recording passion did not languish. At the time of the migration (in 1852) Jane Maria Richmond made a compact with a school friend (Margaret Taylor) to correspond continuously, each to preserve the letters of the other. Jane Maria maintained this interchange for years, her letters being addressed in the first instance to Miss Mary Elizabeth Hutton, to be read by the English circle before going on to Margaret Taylor in Germany.

[Image of page 8]

Shortly after Sir Harry Atkinson's death (in 1892) the family considered publishing his biography, and Arthur and Jane Maria set to work methodically to gather documentary material covering the first fifty years of the Colony. An imposing quantity was already in their hands. The writing of the life was entrusted in the first instance to Maurice Richmond, who was practising law in Wellington, and he had made some progress in arranging the material until 1900 when he was appointed a lecturer at Victoria University College. In 1902 Arthur Atkinson died, leaving behind a respectable body of material which had been carefully annotated by himself, and by Maurice Richmond, Mrs C. W. Richmond, and others. The next author proposed was Sir Harry's son, S. A. Atkinson. 2 He added something to the documentation and made a short draft for the life, which then hung fire for a while.

At this stage it was proposed that Miss Margaret Shaen 3 should finish the task and she took to England a quantity of the relevant papers. When her effort fell through the papers were returned to New Zealand and on the death of Jane Maria Atkinson (in 1914) they became the care of her daughters Ruth and Mabel. 4 The former had in 1911 informed Miss Shaen that "all of Margaret Taylor's letters were saved for us by Maggie Cobden". 5 This refers presumably to Jane Maria's own letters, some of which have found their way to the collection: others which have not been traced were evidently available in 1931. Margaret Taylor's own letters and those between A. S. Atkinson and his wife and between him and their son (A. R. Atkinson) have not been located.

About 1930 Miss Mary E. Richmond, C.B.E. (1853-1949), and Miss Emily Richmond (1869-1950), the surviving daughters of C. W. Richmond, made a compilation from the letters, partly for the information of the family and partly as historical source material. This was typed by Mr A. H. Reed, M.B.E., of Dunedin and bound in two volumes, copies being deposited in several research libraries in New Zealand. (Those in the General Assembly Library are cited here as vols 38 and 39). It was then that the Misses Richmond intimated to the present editor (who was chief librarian of the General Assembly Library), their intention of presenting the papers as a gift to the nation. The gift was gratefully acknowledged by the Library Committee of Parliament.

EDITOR'S NOTE

When I contemplated the dimensions of the collection and the responsibility of an editor's task I was reminded of Arthur Ponsonby's remark in a similar situation:

While I knew at once that less than one per cent of the papers would actually

[Image of page 9]

be used for quotation or reference, they would all have to be perused and most of them carefully read. 6

The arrangement of the papers entailed a vast amount of research. After the first batch reached the General Assembly Library they were arranged chronologically and bound in folio volumes which, with the journals, were numbered from 1 to 45. Extracts from this series which are used herein are cited by volume and page (e.g., v. 4, 27). Journal extracts are cited by volume only (the date being provided by the entry itself). The later deposit of papers almost equalled in number those already received, and covered a parallel period of time. As it was impracticable to insert them in the volumes already bound they were treated as an additional, or new, series and they are cited herein by year and serial number (e.g., 1858/39, No. 39 of the year 1858).

Most of the early letters in the collection, say those dated in the forties, are written on rice paper, quarto size. Before envelopes were used a blank space was left on the last page for the address. Some correspondents, in view of the high rate of postage, made double use of their paper by writing over it at right angles. Occasionally even a third traverse was made, diagonally. As the rate of postage was reduced personal letters came to be written on small octavo sheets and enclosed in envelopes. The advent of the daily newspaper and telegraphy profoundly affected both the character and the volume of personal correspondence.

Handwriting as a medium survived practically the whole period covered by the collection, say 1840 to 1900. With few exceptions the writing is excellent. Alfred Domett, F. Dillon Bell, and William Fox all wrote flowing, clerkly hands. Stafford's large writing is undisciplined and sometimes difficult to decipher, but not so difficult as the thin upright script of Henry Sewell, whose variations make it impossible at times to distinguish one letter of the alphabet from another.

The main difficulty in this, as in other manuscript collections, is defective dating. All too many writers omitted the day, the month, or the year. Sometimes the information could be gleaned from internal evidence in the letter, watermarks in the paper or a search of contemporary newspapers and official papers. Governor Gore Browne, notoriously negligent in dating his letters, had a habit of dashing off short notes and ejaculations signed by his familiar monogram "T.G.B." Few indeed are fully dated, many bear no date at all, only the hour of day. There are still some of these memoranda which cannot be located with confidence.

Mindful that the interpretation of documents is the privilege of the historian, the editor has limited his intervention to clearing up obscurities in the text. The purpose of the introductory chapter ("A Pool of Perplexity") and of the commentaries to each section of the book is to furnish a background of public events and personalities relevant to the period. Footnotes indicated by Arabic numbers are the editor's. Those which occur in the writers' text follow the extract to which they refer and are indicated by the authors' symbols, e.g., *, **, t

[Image of page 10]

About 4,000 extracts from letters and journals have been reproduced. Some extracts, of which the original has not been seen, have been copied from the typescript volumes 38 and 39. Extracts from papers brought in from other collections (notably the Stafford, D. McLean, Rolleston, John Hall, Andrew Sinclair, I. E. Featherston, and Gore Browne) have been checked by the originals in the libraries having custody of them. Certain variations in style, punctuation and spelling are as in the original.

Acknowledgments

In the early days of my work on this interesting collection I had the great advantage of advice and information from the Misses Mary and Emily Richmond, who were uniquely qualified to elucidate a multitude of family details. I deeply appreciated their encouragement and confidence, which led to the presentation of this magnificent gift to the nation, unaccompanied by any conditions.

Of the present generation who responded freely to requests for information I would mention Miss Janet Atkinson (Wellington), Dr Helen Simpson (Christchurch), Mrs C. R. Fell (Nelson), Miss A. M. Hursthouse (Mahina Bay), Mr H. M. W. Atkinson (York Bay), Mr H. P. Richmond, Q.C. (Auckland), Mr H. A. Atkinson (Christchurch), Mr H. T. Atkinson (Nelson), and Vice-Admiral Sir Maxwell Richmond, D.S.O., O.B.E. Lieutenant-Colonel Sir Stewart Gore-Browne, C.B., D.S.O. (Northern Rhodesia), not only assisted with information but later presented to the New Zealand Archives many documents connected with his grandfather's term as Governor of New Zealand.

I have to thank the heads of many research libraries in New Zealand, Australia, and the United Kingdom for their willing assistance in solving problems within their means, and Mr Pei te Hurinui Jones (Taumarunui) for translating a number of Maori letters. Professors I. A. Gordon, F. L. Wood and H. A. Murray, and Dr J. C. Beaglehole, of Victoria University of Wellington, responded most helpfully whenever I sought their advice.

I am indebted to the Government Printer, Mr R. E. Owen, and to his Copy Supervisor, Mr F. A. Davey, for their cordial cooperation in the publication. Frances Porter, M.A., gave valuable assistance in preparing the work for press, including the compilation of the index.

Publication of the Papers has been made possible by financial aid from the Department of Internal Affairs both for editorial emoluments and towards the cost of production of the present volumes. The New Zealand Literary Fund Advisory Committee recommended the production to the Department and acted helpfully in association with myself. I desire to acknowledge the consideration given to me throughout these negotiations by the Secretary for Internal Affairs Mr A. G. Harper, now Sir Arthur Harper.

42 Watt Street, Wellington. - - - GUY H. SCHOLEFIELD

[LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS]

[Image of page 13]

List of Illustrations

Facing page 80

The Victory. The barque Victory, copy by Anderson and Atkinson, Wellington, from original painting by J. C. Richmond, photo from the Taranaki Early Colonist Collection, New Plymouth Public Library and Museum.

Auckland in 1858: Panorama of the city of Auckland from the painting by J. Bunney from the Rex Nan Kivell Collection, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 81

Stone Cottage, New Plymouth: Early Richmond home, photo from a painting in possession of Mr O'Reilly, Tasman Hotel, New Plymouth.

New Plymouth, early 60's: Showing Marsland Hill Barracks, upper left, photo by Callis, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 96

John Hursthouse: Photo W. and D. Downey, Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Helen Hursthouse (nee Wilson): Photo W. and D. Downey, Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Maria Richmond (Lely): Photo Byrne Richmond, Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Emily E. Richmond (nee Atkinson): Photo A. Fletcher, in Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Facing page 97

J. C. Richmond: Photo Maull and Polyblank, Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Mary Richmond (nee Smith): Photo Maull and Polyblank, Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

A. S. Atkinson: Photo Tyree in Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Jane Maria Atkinson (nee Richmond): Photo W. Davis, in Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

[Image of page 14]

Facing page 304

H. A. Atkinson: Photo (c.a. 1860) in Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

C. W. Richmond: Photo in Volume 39, Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

E. W. Stafford: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph. T. King: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 305

H. Sewell: From Schmidt Collection, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

F. D. Fenton: From Schmidt Collection, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

D. McLean: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

I. E. Featherston: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 320

Rev. J. Whiteley: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

B. G. Holmes: Photo Owen Angel, in Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

Charles Brown: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Sir George Grey: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 321

R. R. Parris: Photo Wilbar, Auckland, in possession of H. P. Richmond, Q.c.

I. N. Watt: From Taranaki Early Colonist Collection, New Plymouth Public Library and Museum.

A. Domett: From Schmidt Collection, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Mary Domett: Photo W. Davis, in Richmond-Atkinson Collection in General Assembly Library.

[Image of page 15]

Facing page 576

Richmond Home, Carrington Road, New Plymouth in 1855: From the Taranaki Early Colonist Collection, New Plymouth Public Library and Museum.

Harriet Gore Browne: Photo in possession of her grandson, Lieut. Col. Sir Stewart Gore Browne, D.S.O., Mpika, Northern Rhodesia.

Col. T. Gore Browne: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 577

Sketch map of Taranaki.

Facing page 592

Rev. J. Morgan: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Te Heuheu (Iwikau): Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Te Wherowhero Potatau, 1st Maori King: Portrait by G. F. Angas, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Te Wherowhero Tawhiao Matutaera Potatau, 2nd Maori King: Painting by G. Lindower, Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Facing page 593

Wellington in 1860's, from Tinakori Hills, St. Pauls Church, centre: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Archdeacon (afterwards Bishop) Hadfield, by courtesy of Mr J. W. Marshall, Rangitikei: Alexander Turnbull Library photograph.

Bishop Selwyn, engraved by W. Hale, 1878-9 from a photograph by Messrs Mason and Co.: Alexander Turnbull Library.

[Image of page 16]

Abbreviations

A.D., Dom, Alfred Domett
A.E.R., Anneliz, Ann Elizabeth Richmond (Mrs Tudor Atkinson)
A.-G., Attorney-General
Anna, daughter of C. W. Richmond
Annie {nee Smith) Lady Atkinson
A.R.A., Arfie, Arthur Richmond Atkinson
A.S.A., Ar, Birdie, Arthur Samuel Atkinson
Bill, William S. Atkinson
C.F.R., Kit, Christopher Francis (son of C. W. Richmond)
C.M.S., Church Missionary Society
C.W.R.,(Christopher) William Richmond
Dec, Decy, Decimus Atkinson
D.K.R., Dorothy K. Richmond
Eliza, Mrs W. S. Atkinson {nee Ronalds)
Emily, Emily Richmond (1869-1950), daughter of C. W. Richmond
E.E.R., Emily, Mrs C. W. Richmond (nee Emily Elizabeth Atkinson)
E.W.S., Edward William Stafford
F.D.B., Francis Dillon Bell (1821-98)
H.A.A., Hal, Harry, (Sir) Harry A. Atkinson
H.B., Hawke's Bay
H.E., His Excellency (the Governor)
Helen, Mrs John Hursthouse (nee Wilson)
Helen, Mrs A. C. P. Macdonald (nee Hursthouse)
H.H., His Honour (the Superintendent)
H.R.R., Henry, Henry Robert Richmond
H.S., Sewellus, Henry Sewell

J.C.R., James, J. C. Richmond
Jane, Mrs H. A. Atkinson (nee Skinner)
J.M.A., J.M.R., or Maria, Jane Maria
Atkinson (nee Richmond)
Lely, Maria Richmond (1791-1872)
L.M.S., London Missionary Society
Margaret, Margie, Margaret Taylor
Maria, Maria Richmond (Lely)
Maria, (rarely), Jane Maria Atkinson
Marion, Mrs Decimus Atkinson (nee Ronalds)
Mary, Mrs J. C. Richmond (nee Smith)
Mary, M.E.R., Mary E. Richmond, C.B.E. (1853-1949)
Maurice, Maurice W. Richmond
M.E.H., Meh, Mary Elizabeth Hutton
M.G.A., Member of General Assembly
M.H.R., Member of House of Representatives (to 1907)
M.L.C., Member of Legislative Council
M.P., Member of Parliament (from 1907)
M.P.C., Member of Provincial Council
N.Z.C., New Zealand Cross
N.Z.E.F., New Zealand Expeditionary Force (1914-19)
P.B., Poverty Bay
P.C., Provincial Council
Richie, Richmond Hursthouse
T.G.B., Col. Thomas Gore Browne
W.S.A., Bill, William S. Atkinson
William, C. W. Richmond

1961 - The Richmond-Atkinson Papers Vol I - [Front Matter] p 1-16